Is Manufactured Stone Better Than Real Stone?

Choosing between manufactured stone and real stone for home projects? The decision can feel overwhelming. Both materials offer unique benefits and aesthetic appeal, but they also come with trade-offs. So, which is better, manufactured stone or real stone? The answer largely depends on your priorities, such as budget, installation, durability, and design preferences. Let’s explore the pros and cons of each to help you make the best choice for your home.

What Is manufactured stone?

Manufactured stone, also known as manufactured stone veneer (MSV), is a man-made product designed to replicate the look of natural stone. It’s typically made from a blend of cement, lightweight aggregates, and pigments, molded into shapes and textures that mimic real stone.

The pros of manufactured stone

1. Cost-effective: one of the most significant advantages of manufactured stone is its affordability. MSV tends to be far less expensive than natural stone, not only in terms of the material itself but also when considering installation costs. This makes it a popular option for homeowners looking to achieve a luxurious stone look without breaking the bank.

2. Lightweight and easy to install: manufactured stone is much lighter than real stone, which makes it easier to handle and install. Its lightweight nature means it doesn’t require the same structural support as natural stone, allowing it to be applied in a wider variety of situations, such as interior walls, fireplaces, or exterior cladding. The reduced weight also means lower shipping and labor costs, further contributing to its affordability.

3. Versatility in design: MSV is available in a wide range of colors, shapes, and textures, offering more design flexibility than natural stone. Manufacturers can replicate different types of stone, from ledgestone to rugged fieldstone, giving you endless options to match your home’s aesthetic. Additionally, custom pieces and custom colors can sometimes be made to order if you have a specific design in mind.

4. Consistency in appearance: because manufactured stone is man-made, each piece is uniform in size and shape, making it easier to work with, especially for projects requiring precise measurements. This consistency can make for a smoother installation process and a more polished final look.

5. Eco-friendly: some manufactured stone products are made with recycled materials, reducing the environmental impact compared to quarrying and transporting natural stone. Additionally, the lightweight nature of MSV means it requires less energy to transport, further reducing its carbon footprint.

The cons of manufactured stone

1. Appearance: although high-quality manufactured stone can look incredibly realistic, it may not have the same depth and richness as natural stone. Close inspection can sometimes reveal a more artificial look, especially with lower-grade products. The uniformity that is an advantage during installation can also be a disadvantage if you prefer the natural variations and imperfections found in real stone.

2. Resale value: while manufactured stone can enhance the appearance of your home, it doesn’t carry the same perceived value as natural stone. Homebuyers may prefer the authenticity of real stone, which can affect your home’s resale value in the long term.

What is real stone?

Real stone, as the name implies, is quarried directly from the earth. It includes materials like granite, limestone, sandstone, and slate, each with its own unique properties and visual appeal.

The pros of real stone

1. Authentic beauty: there’s no denying the timeless appeal of real stone. Its natural variations in color, texture, and veining create a unique, organic look that can’t be replicated. Each piece of real stone is one-of-a-kind, giving your project a sense of authenticity and luxury.

2. Potentially higher resale value: homes featuring real stone can have higher perceived resale values because of the material’s prestige. Natural stone can be seen as a premium product, potentially making it a desirable feature for potential buyers.

 The cons of real stone

1. High cost: one of the biggest drawbacks of real stone is its cost. Natural stone is significantly more expensive than manufactured stone, both in terms of material and installation. The heavy weight of real stone requires additional structural support, which can increase installation costs.

2. Difficult installation: real stone is much heavier and harder to work with than manufactured stone. Its weight and irregular shapes can make installation more labor-intensive, requiring skilled masons to complete the job. This not only adds to the cost but also lengthens the project timeline.

3. Limited design options: while natural stone is beautiful, your design options are limited by what is available in nature. You can’t custom-order real stone in specific colors or shapes, which may be a limitation if you have a particular vision for your project.

Is manufactured stone better than real stone?

Ultimately, the decision comes down to your project’s specific needs and your personal preferences. Both manufactured stone and real stone have their advantages and drawbacks. Manufactured stone offers a versatile, cost-effective alternative that mimics the look of natural stone, while real stone provides unmatched authenticity. Your final decision should be based on your budget and aesthetic goals. Whether you go with manufactured stone or real stone, both can elevate the look and value of your home when chosen and installed correctly.

What's next?

Ready to elevate your design? Shop now or order a sample to experience the quality and texture firsthand!

Have a question?

Please see our full terms of service.

For general information and questions please call: (864) 882-8960 Mon. - Fri. 8am - 5pm (EST) or email: info@mountainviewstone.net we are more than happy to help you.

Or you can submit your questions via our contact us page.

We look forward to working with you on your upcoming project.

The Mountain View Stone Team